Rays of Light

Posts Tagged ‘Marc Topkin’

Oh Marc Topkin, why must you lie?

Sunday, January 27th, 2008

I’m not one to steal Cork’s thunder and rip on one of the Rays’ columnists (okay, maybe I am), but there was something in Marc Topkin’s article in the Times today that irked me. (St. Pete Times)

No, it wasn’t that he spent 11 paragraphs on Scott Kazmir’s reaction to James Shields’ deal without telling us anything. I’ve come to expect that.

No, it wasn’t that he invoked Toby Hall’s name in there, bringing back painful memories that I’d like to forget.

It was that he said that you could “field a decent team” with the following players still available via free agency:

1B Doug Mientkiewicz, 2B Jerry Hairston, SS Royce Clayton, 3B Jeff Cirillo, C Mike Piazza, OF Luis Gonzalez, OF Kenny Lofton, OF Brad Wilkerson, DH Barry Bonds, P Kyle Lohse, P Livan Hernandez, P Jeff Weaver, P Odalis Perez, P Trever Miller, P David Wells

Seems like an innocent enough comment, right? That is until you realize that lots of people rely on writers like Topkin to give them accurate information. Let’s organize that group into a lineup and a starting rotation, and see exactly what we’ve got.

  1. CF - Kenny Lofton, Age: 40 OPS+: 105
  2. SS - Royce Clayton, Age: 38 OPS+: 66
  3. C - Mike Piazza, Age: 39 OPS+: 96 (And can’t field a lick)
  4. DH - Barry Bonds, Age: 43 OPS+: 170 (With a ton of baggage)
  5. RF - Brad Wilkerson, Age: 30 OPS+: 104
  6. LF - Luis Gonzalez, Age: 40 OPS+: 104
  7. 3B - Jeff Cirillo, Age: 38 OPS+: 81
  8. 1B - Doug Mientkiewicz, Age: 33 OPS+: 107
  9. 2B - Jerry Hairson, Age: 31 OPS+: 42
  1. Livan Hernandez, Age: 33 ERA+: 95
  2. David Wells, Age: 44 ERA+: 77
  3. Odalis Perez, Age: 30 ERA+: 84
  4. Jeff Weaver, Age: 31 ERA+: 70
  5. Kyle Lohse, Age: 30 ERA+: 100

Why are you lying to us, Marc?!? Why?? This isn’t a decent team at all! This team is AWFUL! It would go like 50-112! Not only that, but it’s OLD so you’d be playing with guys who are even worse for most of the year. Ugh!

There were a few decent tidbits in Topkin’s article, including:

  • Carl Crawford is working out harder than ever and could be coming to camp in the best shape of his life. Nice. High-five!
  • Keith Law ain’t having any of the James Shields deal. He shares the concerns that I initially had about it until I realized that this was a monumental step in the right direction for the franchise in that it was willing to spend money to reward good performance rather than just selling it off to the highest bidder.
  • Rocco Baldelli took in a soccer game, and will be out for three months after a rowdy Celtic supported yelled too loud and ruptured his ear drum. Okay, I made the injury part up. But Rocco does love him some Celtic (that’s KEL-tick) football.
  • Jake McGee is hangin’ with James Shields, checking out his workouts.

Alright, time to go run some errands before the NHL All-Star Game. I expect all y’all to tune in, too.

Weekend Wrap-up

Monday, January 14th, 2008

Here’s what you may have missed over the weekend while writing cuss words on your checks to pay for parking tickets:

Marc Topkin checked in with a bunch of notes in the Sunday St. Pete Times:

  • About the utility player the Rays want:

    The preferred profile for the wanted “super-utility” player is a left-handed hitter who can play first and third and fill in at the corner outfield spots, and likely would be acquired via trade.

    Though I’m not sure why they’d want a LEFTY to play first since that’s what Carlos Pena is and the addition of this player would likely mean the end of Joel Guzman’s chances of making the roster, that player they are talking about sounds an awful lot like Frank Catalanotto. Problem is, he makes $3.5 million and plays for another team (Texas), so the Rays would have to swing some kind of trade. I don’t see that happening.

  • As is being reported for about the 10th time, the Rays are going beyond the original payroll estimate of $40 million.

    “From the original thoughts that all of us had, we’re a good bit above that number and it’s just the way things worked out,” Friedman said. “It’s the opportunistic approach that we had this offseason.”

    I don’t think it’s ever been a question of getting to $40 million and stopping there. I think the team was truly taking the approach that it would spend whatever it needed to spend so long as it remained within the plan - the plan of course being to continue to develop the majority of its talent from within. The money spent on Troy Percival, for instance, was the right move to make and the organization should be commended for being willing to shell out a little more cash than it said it was going to.

  • I’m thinking Topkin might be taking the blog route and just reposting the news of the week because he said, as we’ve heard a number of times already, that the decision on Evan Longoria’s status will likely come prior to Spring Training.

    t would seem an unusual way to do things, but Friedman said the Rays might decide before 3B prospect Evan Longoria gets to spring training whether or not he’s on the team.

    The thinking is that the Rays already know enough about him, that talent evaluations during the spring are often skewed by circumstance and level of competition, and that deciding beforehand would reduce scrutiny (and pressure) on his day-to-day play.

    But doing so would seem to make sense only if they decide Longoria, 22, isn’t going to make the team. That way, it eliminates the question from being a daily issue, as well as a potential controversy if Longoria were to put up huge spring numbers.

    I have to disagree with Topkin on the point that it only makes sense if he isn’t going to make the team. “It eliminates the question from being a daily issue”? Uhhh, this isn’t the New York media, pal. I suspect that you, Marc Lancaster, and Bill Chastain aren’t going to exactly crush the guy’s spirits with your reporting over the course of Spring Training. You might just be overstating your job a little, don’t you think?

  • Rocco Baldelli watch: He is actually running and hasn’t hurt himself… yet.

    Baldelli said he has been working out and running three days a week with no problems from his previously troubling hamstrings and plans to “turn it up a notch” after returning to Florida at the end of the month. “If I can hit and kind of take it easy running, I think everything will fall right into place after that,” he said.

    That’s right. Rocco’s getting ready to “turn it up a notch.” Look out, AL East.

    In all seriousness, the return of a healthy Baldelli would be a boon to this team because it simply adds an All-Star-caliber player to an already strong team. Considering how little he was around last season, it’s almost like another big free agent signing.

  • No, seriously…

    And for those who keep asking, the Trop can’t be “converted” to an outdoor stadium by removing the roof and some walls because it was built with no drainage or weatherproofing (and would be very costly to do).

    WHO ASKED THIS QUESTION?! No, seriously. I want to know. Was it one of you guys?


  • Elsewhere in the Raysverse, the team is playing the “it will give more money to schools” card as it relates to the new stadium. Not a bad move, considering reaction on the project seems mixed at best. (St. Pete Times)

    The Rays say the successful redevelopment of Tropicana Field and its parking lots could generate $5-million a year in new property tax revenues for state and Pinellas schools. If the redevelopment includes retail, millions more dollars could flow into the city and county coffers each year through sales tax payments.

    That money, which would not help build a new stadium for the Rays, could be used to build new schools or new parks or pay teachers or police officers more, the Rays say.

    Watching this whole thing play out is like watching a politician who is 5 to 10 points down in the polls try to make up ground heading into a primary.

  • I’m not going to steal The Professor’s thunder on this one, since he already wrote pretty much what I would’ve written about it, but Joe Maddon made it a point to say last week that .500 is a reasonable goal for this team. (Tampa Tribune)

    The blend of talent and experience has the manager talking about a .500 season as “a reasonable goal,” but it won’t deter him from taking a back-to-basics approach to spring training. In fact, the potential to crack the 70-win barrier for the first time in Rays history might only serve to reinforce Maddon’s determination to avoid giving away so many winnable games by committing fundamental mistakes.

    “I’m going to apply a lot of pressure to the coaches and myself this spring training to make sure we get these fundamentals down appropriately,” Maddon said. “We’ve talked about them for two years; I believe this group is ready to put them into play. I believe this group is ready to take what we’re talking about and execute them. I believe this group will accept constructive criticism well and be accountable for their actions.

    As soon as you shoot for mediocrity, you set yourself up for failure. Way to go, Joe. This team - like every team’s goal - should be to win as many games as possible and ultimately reach the playoffs. But, nah, let’s shoot for a third-place finish and the chance to watch Joe Buck annoy the fans of two other teams instead of ours in the playoffs.