View From The Bleachers

March 15, 2011

Around the MLB: Breakout Players

Filed under: Featured,General — Daniel Beacher @ 8:50 am

Like any fan of the game, right now is an anxious time for me. We’re under 30 days away from 7 months of stolen bases, double plays, and diving catches. Three weeks from a first look at new rookies and to reconnect with familiar faces, some in different uniforms.

By February, I’m out of hibernation and thinking and reading about baseball all through out the day, just to have something to snack on until April. Most of the time, the same names pop up: Albert Pujols, Jose Bautista, and for some reason, Ozzie Guillen. The current media storm is in perpetual motion, swirling over the same stories as it awaits results, any results at all, from baseball. But I’m just not interested in how much more monopoly money Mr. Pujols will have dumped in his back yard come payday, since negotiations aren’t even currently in progress. Instead, how about turning up the hype on a fresh batch of players who could be ready to make headlines on the diamond in the next couple of months?

Last year, I spotlighted a couple players in my mind, researching their statistics from the following year and looking ahead to how their 2010 season may develop.

Here was my list, in no particular order, of players I wanted to keep an eye on:

Lind & Hill in Toronto

A. Jones & Markakis in Baltimore

Ubaldo Jimenez

Evan Longoria

Shin-Soo Choo

Franklin Gutierrez

Sean Marshall

Ryan Theriot

As we now know, Choo, Longoria, and Marshall put up another solid season. Jones & Markakis were more or less static (more on that later). Ubaldo seemed poised for a 20+ win season, only to fizzle in the second half and wind up a win short. After that, though, the list was a bit disappointing. Lind & Hill both dropped off considerably in batting average and couldn’t approach their powers numbers from 2009. Gutierrez’s numbers regressed, and Ryan Theriot left for LA, and then came back to the NL Central on what he called the “right” side of the rivalry (Whatever. It’s spelled “Ryne” by the way, Mr. Redbird.)

The closest to a breakout season in 2010 was Ubaldo. By July last year, he was the hands-down pick for Cy Young. After that, it varies across the board, and you could get into a range of debates as to how the 2010 season fits into each player’s overall career. Personally, I just wanted to remember some guys playing for teams who were likely to miss the playoffs. If these players have breakout seasons, and everything clicks, they could begin to reverse that general assumption for the organization. Or they just put up another good year, and need to be recognized for it, a la Shin Soo Choo.

Obviously my list has changed going into 2011. I had to accommodate some rookies who pounced on the 2010 season, as well as give veteran status to the guys who were earning it (Yep, that eliminates Longoria, Marshall, and Choo). I’m also excluding no-brainers like Buster Posey, Carlos Gonzales and Aroldis Chapman because I know they’ll be applauded (if they’re good) or exiled (if they struggle) by the media on a daily basis.

First off, I’m keeping Adam Jones & Nick Markakis in mind again because they’re the closest to gaining vet status, or at least a better idea of what to expect from them. The last two years, they have each put up an exceptional season. From here, it’s either break out in 2011 and go from good to great in batting average & run production, or produce another consistent season. Either scenario works for these two, but I’m sure Baltimore would like to know what they have in their outfielders so they can figure out how they can build their young team around them.

Tyler Colvin & Andrew Cashner

Attention Cubs fans- these two are potentially dangerous. They hit the scene in 2010 with surprisingly good numbers, and played like they deserved to be in the bigs. But don’t go betting all of your marbles just yet- it’s possible they’re still a year away from a breakout season, and sophomore year can be a tough one. For these two, 2011 is more a question of whether or not to consider them as potential superstars. Will 24 year old Cashner venture in to the rotation after going 2-6 from the pen in 2010? Will Colvin receive more at bats, and if so, can he match his slugging percentage (.500) from last year? And by the way, Starlin Castro may have gotten his breakout season out of the way already, even though I’ll still be paying close attention to how much he improves on defense.

Jason Heyward

He didn’t waste any time last year, lighting up the Cubs on opening day if I remember correctly. What stood out to me was the sound the ball made coming off his bat and a sweet swing that seemed to resemble Ken Griffey Jr.’s. He was a sure fire runner up for rookie of the year, with 18 knocks, 72 runs driven in and a robust OBP (.393), even while sustaining a minor injury. Heyward is my pick for this year. I don’t think he’s going to waste any time in putting up elite Major League numbers, as long as he stays healthy.

James Loney

I still resent Loney for what he did to the Cubs in 2008, but you can’t ignore his talent. He represents the middle of a young Dodger core, just about at the same level as Matt Kemp and Andre Ethier as they steadily produce runs. Loney contributed with 88 RBI last year, but his batting average dipped to .267. If Ethier returns to 2009 form, and Kemp and Loney can raise their averages, the Dodgers have a reliable trio on the right side of the field.

Ike Davis

Davis was fun to watch in 2010. Amidst a full bloom of NL rookies, Davis played stellar defense in his first full year; He also produced on offense with a .791 OPS, even chipping in a couple times in the clutch with some walk-off hits. The problem- Davis plays for the Mets. He seems an obvious cornerstone candidate for a rebuilding franchise, but will instead have to silently play as his team crumbles around him. Above anything else, I’m rooting for Davis to get traded to, well, any other team. Unfortunately, it’s still highly unlikely he changes uniforms, even though the Mets are imploding going into 2011.

Mike Leake

Similar to his NL Central counterparts on this list, the question is a matter of how seriously to take Mike Leake. He put on some brilliant clinics from the mound last year, making hitters look foolish with Greg Maddux-like poise and control. This only amounted to 8 wins for the Reds in 2010, but each one seemed a masterpiece. Those kinds of pitchers, if they can maintain in the pros, have long, solid careers, and that’s no easy feat. At 23, Leake was somewhat rushed to the Majors, and his impressive numbers could just be a reflection of hitters being ambushed by his potent arsenal of pitches. He’s at least worth keeping tabs on in 2011 and could have a high ceiling in the coming years.

Nelson Cruz

Cruz may be a bit of a throw-in, since he’s already well established in the majors. He finally shined in 2010 with an all star selection and a playoff performance worth noticing. The question for Cruz in 2011 is whether or not he can carry a team. Cruz failed to crack 80 RBI for the second year in a row, but improved his OBP (.374) and SLG (.576) while cutting down on strikeouts. As we saw in 2010, the time to win in Texas is now. Will Cruz rise to superstar status and push them over the brink? If he evolves into a .300/30/110 player, the departure of Cliff Lee and impending loss of Michael Young will sting a little less as the Rangers defend their AL crown.

Ditto to: Jeremy Hellickson, Kurt Suzuki, Mike Napoli, Gaby Sanchez, Shaun Marcum, Cody Ross, & Mat Latos

Like what you see here? Never miss new content. Follow Us:
  • http://van Buddy

    Nice job on the list! My quick thoughts on some of your selections…Heyward is a fantastic player who will soon approach super stardom. Same with Nelson Cruz. Both are elite talents. James Loney doesn’t do much for me. A 1B without power isn’t very valuable in this era of professional baseball (unless he is an onbase machine, which Loney is not). I like Gabby Sanchez, Ike Davis, and Shawn Marcum in 2011. I see regression for Latos, Leake, and Colvin.

  • Lizzie

    Great stuff and great to read you again! Welcome back, to you and to baseball!

  • Chet

    I think Colvin is in for a rough season. It really doesn’t help that they are teaching him a new position at this time either.

  • jswanson

    On the topic of Colvin…it wasn’t like he was slapping singles last season. He is going to step up to the plate and slug again this year. Put him in front of Pena so he sees some fastballs and let him do his thing.

  • Chuck

    Picking highly touted prospects and established young players for “breakout players” is not exactly taking a big risk. It is like predicting that Aramis will get hurt during the year, Soriano and Pena will strike out a lot and the sun will rise tomorrow morning.
    My Cubs breakout player is DeWitt. His still young (will be 25 this year), has been in the bigs for a couple of years and gets on base a bit (0.333 OBP last 3 years). I can see him hitting .280-.290 with a .350 OBP and playing solid defense. Not a star but a good solid 2B for years to come.

  • http://van Buddy

    I’d be thrilled with those numbers for DeWitt. Consider my fingers crossed!

  • Doc Raker

    I don’t think it is so easy to pick break out players, I remember once upon a time a one Korey Patterson was tabbed to be a break out player.

  • BuckeyeLakerCub

    I’m with Doc. Look at Soto. He had a phenomenal rookie year, and I’m sure all of us thought we’ve got ourselves a catcher for the next decade, and then he stunk up the joint in 2009, and has yet to regain his 2008 form.

  • Buddy

    I agree with Doc. Almost every “expert” on Earth was calling Matt Wieters the next Mike Piazza two years ago.

  • Aaron

    Corey Patterson, Eric Patterson, Hee Sop Choi, God-knows-how-many pitchers, now Josh Vitters is fizzling before even getting to the majors… The list of Cubs potential breakout players who never quite made it keeps going longer than the Energizer Bunny.

  • Chuck

    I understand that it is hard to peg breakout players. But Evan Longloria? Really? The dude has been an All Star the past three years and won two Gold Gloves. He is not exactly flying under the radar.
    How about Kimbrel of the Braves. The guy can throw 100 and may be the closer for them.
    Logan Morrison the outfielder for the Marlins.

  • jswanson

    Not to mention his role on Desparate Housewives…

  • Mitchener

    Player A : 396PA 22HR 59RBI 5SB 34BB 123SO .259/.326/.507/.833
    PLayer B: 394PA 20 HR 56RBI 5SB 30BB 100 SO .254/.316/.500/.816

    These two players are very similar in stats. Player A is Mike Stanton (2010 #3 Prospect) and Player B is Tyler Colvin. Both of these guys were in there rookie season and both were right fielders, but Tyler Colvin is already being written off by some as the next Francouer and Stanton as the next superstar. Colvin even posted a better SO to BB ratio, which was one of the concerns with Colvin. Colvin seems determined to improve, he has been training offseason and working at first base. I dont see him regressing like Wells and Soto who both seemed unprepared for their sophomore season. Soto had weight issues and Randy Wells admitted he got to big for britches. So i believe Colvin will be close to last years numbers or better.

  • Melber

    hey beach, nice job man i enjoyed reading that, keep em’ comin. I think you really nailed the NL side of the house, we all know you are all little racist against us AL types. Yeah i really agree on Heyward man, im thinkin’ his upcoming season will be massive if he stays healthy. Watch out for Iglesias , super impressive SS who will definitly see some time for us ( u know who) this year and if scutaro hits the DL he will really get his chance to step up. Im so pumped for this season, i will be able to keep track the entire season for once without any vacations like the one im on now.

  • Buddy

    Check out Stanton’s very impressive minor league numbers when you get a chance. Also, the guy is a freak of nature physically.

  • Chuck

    The majorly huge difference between the two is age. Colvin will be a youngish 25 this year while Stanton will be 21. The 4 years age difference is huge when comparing young players.

  • Danny B


    Thanks man. Glad to hear you get to enjoy a full season, I’m expecting you to keep me updated on the AL. Perhaps a visit to Wrigley even? I’m going Opening Day weekend, can’t frickin wait.

    As for Mr. Colvin, I’d like to see him get more at-bats, but meaningful ones. Train him on getting on base and swinging for the gaps since there’s so many power bats around him in the lineup.

  • Doc Raker

    The media and scouts love size and muscle but size and muscle isn’t all there is to it. The big league reality of having a hole in your swing doesn’t go away with size and muscle so we will just have to watch and see who really does break out and progress along playing the greatest game.

  • Buddy

    True enough Doc. Having said that, I’m still betting on big things from Mike Stanton (the Marlins OF, not the old Braves pitcher).

  • BuckeyeLakerCub

    @Doc – Well said. Give me a ballplayer first. Size and muscle are things that can be acquired. I don’t care if you’re the strongest man on the planet, if you can’t hit a 100 mph fastball or a 60 mph slider, or anything in between, you don’t belong in the majors.

  • Seymour O’Butts

    I thought we weren’t supposed to put love, size and muscle in the same sentence.

  • jswanson

    If you use love, size, muscle, and Geo in the same sentence, you might be on the fast track to a Lizzie.

  • lizzie

    @jswanson you are a quick study. ;-)

Powered by WordPress