I can honestly say that when the Cubs signed Milton Bradley (I believe it was during January of 2009), I had never heard of him. I knew nothing about the history of personal problems which have been rehashed ubiquitously since then. Problems with umpires? I knew nothing. Problems with announcers? Ditto. Problems with anger management? Not on my radar.
I didn’t know Milton Bradley from the man in the moon.
I do not think that mental illness is a laughing matter. I don’t think mental illness is something to make fun of, or to joke about. I also don’t think mental illness is something to be overlooked in structuring a long term, multimillion dollar contract.
I was recently reminded of the time when the Cubs traded Lou Brock to the Cardinals for Ernie Broglio. Ernie Broglio, a former multiyear 20 game winner with St. Louis, won less than 20 games total for the Cubs over the next 3 years.
Current reports are that Broglio, prior to the trade, had incurred an injury, a physical infirmity, which might have been identified during a physical exam, had such an exam occurred in conjunction with the trade.
Did the Cardinals know about the preexisting condition? I don’t know. Were they required to disclose the existence of any such condition? I don’t know. Did Ernie Broglio take it upon himself to mention it? I don’t know. Was he required to? I don’t know.
Back then, successful completion of a routine physical exam as a condition of the trade was not commonly required. Now, of course, I cannot imagine a player trade or a free agent signing NOT being contingent upon obtaining a clean bill of physical health.
So, maybe, in the aftermath of Mr. Bradley’s recent situation with the Chicago Cubs, ball clubs will require psychiatric/psychological testing prior to entering into agreements with free agents or with other teams. I expect the player’s union to oppose such a development on the grounds of player confidentiality or some such consideration. But the Cubs/Milton Bradley train wreck demonstrates that the time for universal psychological/psychiatric testing of major league ballplayers has arrived. For the good of the game.
At the very least, the industry standard might evolve to include a clause mandating that player contracts will be voided should a mental illness develop or should a mental disorder become evident during the life of the agreement.
Clearly, there is no upside to the Cubs/Bradley situation. It’s not good for the player. It’s not good for the team. It’s not good for Major League Baseball. It’s not good for the fans. It’s a bad situation. I hope the Chicago Cubs have learned their lesson.

Umm… what mental illness or disorder did Bradley have?
I don’t know about voiding contracts; wouldn’t that be discriminatory? I do think at least a mental health exam would be good. Unless he actually gets professionally examined, we can only accuse Milton of being bat-poop crazy (serious anger management issues). If I were a GM taking on someone with a bad history like Bradley’s, i know I’d try to make it a condition of his contract to have weekly sessions with a therapist!
If I didn’t despise Milton for all the trouble he brought, I might feel sorry for him. He’s a guy so clearly lost and incapable of controlling himself. He has talent, but it’s always going to be overshadowed by his wretched attitude. It’s never his fault; it’s always someone else’s. He’ll be lucky not to wind up in retirement due to no one wanting him.
Calling Milton Bradley mentally ill is an insult to the infirm.
Just teasing, but having a bad attitude, playing the victim, assigning blame to whoever happens to be convenient, never looking inward even after many many years worth of problems with many different teams … I don’t think that’s mentally ill. I think it’s selfish, arrogant, spoiled, etc. etc. ad nauseum. But we all know plenty of people like that, and while they may benefit from some counseling I don’t think they warrant any specific diagnosis. To me that’s like giving him an excuse.
I think most prospects go through phsych testing. As for Hasbro, Hendry had plenty of history to draw from, the Cubs shouldn’t have needed any additional tests- Hasbro has been a malcontent were ever he has been.
You can’t void contracts based on inury or illness, physical or mental. I do think gauranteed contracts are a problem for baseball but it would take a NHL type of a season long lockout to get that changed. I would be happy with a hard salary cap.
The legal ramifications of denying contracts based on “mental illness” are probably not something the MLB is ever going to want to touch. And no amount of testing is going to prevent selfish, arrogant, or spoiled players from being in MLB. Those are poor characteristics to have, of course, but it doesn’t mean someone is unfit to play.
That being said, I also don’t exactly think we can (or should) all play armchair pyschiatrist and diagnose Milton Bradley with an illness. I’m pretty sure it’s safe to say he is a butthead, though.
When Milton lost his head during his first game in Wrigley, I got a steady stream of “see, clubhouse cancer!” messages from my AL friends. He was managable until he started slumping, then completely lost it.
Seems like an ego problem. It must be difficult, making the transition from center of attention to team player, but most adults can cope. Paul Oneil…Reggie Jackson…they made it work.
Hasbro is from Poly High School in Long Beach CA, I practice in Long Beach and know people who knew him in high school,i.e. classmates, coaches etc. He was a problem personality then and apparently has never changed. Don’t hold you breath waiting for him to change. Hendry thought he could sit down to dinner and have a conversation with him, pay him $10M per and make him a changed man, not so. Kinda akin to Obama changing the Iranian lunatic with a conversation over a hooka and tea. Don’t hold your breath for either.
Greetings to all! I hope you are enjoying a pleasant Holiday season. Thanks for reading and thanks for commenting. Let me address the comments in reverse order:
Doc,
- You learn something every day. I did not know that Milton Bradley hails from Long Beach.
- I can see why an observer might describe Milton as having a “problem personality”.
- As far as “holding my breath”; like I said, “Breathe deeply, exhale slowly”.
jswanson,
- “Lost his head” is a good way of describing it. Not particularly fun to watch, at least not for me.
Kris,
- I’m not a lawyer, so I won’t speculate on “legal ramifications”. I would ask how you feel about taking into account a player’s psychological makeup when calibrating that player’s worth to a team?
- Now “butthead”; there’s a nice, descriptive term. I like it!
- I agree that “armchair psychiatrist” is not something we should be playing. Attempting to establish a diagnosis without proper examination is not too terribly accurate.
- I reread my post, above, to verify that I did not ascribe to Milton Bradley the diagnosis of “mentally ill”. I simply suggested that, in light of Mr. Bradley’s well documented history of “controversies”, (particularly during this past year), perhaps, in the future, mental illness should be ruled out, and personalities should be evaluated, as a routine part of professional player evaluation.
Doc,
- If what you say is true, then maybe the guy who signed him without contractual safeguards needs to have HIS head examined.
- You could certainly structure a contract with incentives (and disincentives) spelling out what will be rewarded and what will not be rewarded. You could base additional vesting years upon those same parameters.
lizzie,
- You are my favorite regularly scheduled Friday poster at VFTB.
- I’m not calling anybody anything.
- I agree that “having a bad attitude, playing the victim, assigning blame to whoever happens to be convenient, never looking inward even after many many years worth of problems with many different teams …” is selfish, arrogant, spoiled, etc. etc. ad nauseum. It also pretty much fits the textbook definitions of “paranoid personality”, “psychopathic personality”, and “personality disorder”.
- I think “people like that” do warrant a specific diagnosis. Treatment, too (if it’s indicated). Certainly before you commit to paying out 30 million dollars.
DB,
- I’m not a lawyer, so I don’t know about about voiding or not voiding contracts because of “discrimination”.
- You bring up a good point about “no one wanting him”. As I was following coverage of the “Indianapolis Follies” a few weeks ago, it occurred to me that if no teams were bidding for Milton’s services, despite the common knowledge that his services were available, then the “free and open market” could be said to have placed his “fair market value” at the major league minimum. That, in itself, should have voided the rest of his obviously “overvalued” contract. I would have enjoyed listening to both sides of THOSE legal arguments.
- Now, DB, tell us why you jumped out of that airplane.
dave,
- Good question. It seems that Mr. Bradley has, over the past decade or so, left a trail of fans, writers, GMs, etc. scratching their heads and asking that very same question. I’m not saying it’s any of our business what the specific diagnosis or diagnoses might be (patient confidentiality and HIPAA regulations mandate that), but MLB and specific teams might want to be aware of what exactly they are dealing with (as a condition of employment). Torn rotator cuff? They’d want to know. Couple of broken legs? They’d want to know. I’m just sayin’.
We’re in agreement, CubbieDude…we’ll call him butthead.
I do think that teams should take a players’ personality into account when they sign them. I’ve always assumed they do that during meetings, etc. before the signing. (Then again–that seems more typical in the NBA than it does in MLB.)
The problem is that anyone with a brain will be on their best behavior in the interview process. If a guy comes in saying, “I know I have a reputation, but I’ve turned a page in my life” we want to believe them. I’m sure guys like Bradley have their agents telling them exactly what to say in these situations. And I’m sure we’ve all experienced this in our own lives–someone at work who seemed great in an interview and ended up being completely lazy, two-faced, etc.
D’accord, Kris. Butthead it is.
I agree CubbieDude, Hendry should have his head examined after that contract.