
First Star – Kerry Wood (.167)
Second Star – Rich Hill (.156)
Third Star – Jason Bay (.106)
Play of the Game – Fukudome’s triple in the 4th (+.120)
The big story before this game would be the return of Rich Hill to the Cubs rotation after not pitching in eight days. Hill, who has always been a pitcher with good control, faltered with erratic pitching throughout the entirety of Spring Training and into the early season. Hill entered this game with 7 walks in 9 innings pitched. Last start Len Kasper stated that there was a rumor that Rich Hill heard a story about the struggles that another pitcher was having with control and that those stories might be playing with his mind. Again, if this it true we need help.
Also notable before the game was that Eric Patterson would lead off for the Cubs and play second base. This change at the top of the order was somewhat understandable in that Mike Fontenot stranded seven guys on base yesterday. I don’t understand why Patterson is the next choice and I would like to ask you about this later. Recently I have heard about how the eight hole is the hardest place to hit in the lineup- especially in relation to Pie’s struggles.
The Pitching
Rich Hill was not amazing but he was good. This is a good step to recovery for him. It looked real bad when the game started with a four pitch walk to Pirates lead off guy Nate McLouth (Who got thrown out stealing only once in high school, and has never been caught stealing in the majors). Hill was battling early and he looked like he was going to have a mental breakdown. Hill could only get his curve ball over early on but he was helped by a McLouth pick off.
Hill gave up a run in the second when Xavier Nady drove a curve ball into the outfield driving in Jason Bay. The fact that the curve was the go to pitch hurt Hill in this situation but he got better as the day went on. Hill was pulled in the fifth leading 3-1. This was another good move by Lou to try to give Hill the chance for a win, which he got. Hill’s final line: 5ip, (only) 3h, 1er, 3bb, 4k, 82 pitches only 46 for strikes. He struggled but he won…and only gave up one run.
The bullpen was good. At times real good. Lieber got two outs in the sixth after the weird inning and poor performance of yesterday. Marshall got the final out in the sixth. Marmol pitched the seventh and eighth. He gave up a solo home run to McLouth in the eighth. He also had five strikeouts.
Kerry Wood threw a six pitch 1-2-3 ninth inning to get the save.
The Bats
The Cubs really had a bad day at the plate except for the fourth inning. They stranded a lot of guys and missed out on good scoring chances throughout the game. In the first they got runners at the corners with two out and Fukudome could not come through. In the second DeRosa led off with a double but did not move from there. In the third Theriot tripled with one out and did not score. (It reminded me of all of the missed opportunities of yesterday’s game.) They scored all the runs they would score, and fortunately would need, in the fourth. Fukudome leads off with a triple. DeRosa singles him in. Soto doubles and DeRo goes to third. Johnson singles scoring DeRo. Patterson grounds out and Soto scores. 3-1. DeRosa and Johnson were both 2 for 4 today and were on every at bat yesterday. Maybe they could be moved up in the lineup?
Johnson also made a back to the field running catch which was a clear confidence boost to Hill on the mound.
Here was a stunning statistic: The Cubs lead the majors in pitches/ab with 3.96. This has a lot to do with Fukudome who is at 4.63. But I also must say that I think Soriano was taking more pitches this year as well.
Side notes:
Yesterday there was the Henry Blanco bunting fiasco. Henry missed a sign but the bad part was that Mike Quade, third base coach, said “Next time I will walk down and talk to the batter.” Quade should have realized that Blanco missed the sign on strike 2 but did not talk to him about it and allowed him to strike out on a foul bunt. How could you not walk up and tell him? Pathetic. Worst third base coach in baseball…unless Wavin’ Wendell is still around.
I was at the game yesterday and I saw firsthand that the redone field is gorgeous. It also looks a ton safer. No hills around.
I wanted your input…
Who should be leading off and batting second?
I would propose: Johnson, DeRosa, Lee, Ramirez, Fukudome, Soto, Theriot, Fontenot, Pitcher. What do you propose?
Meltdowns
Seeing Hill almost meltdown again today it reminded me of when Rick Ankiel went nuts and could not get the ball to the catcher. And the worst one I remember was (I think) Chuck Knoblauch who went through a phase when he could not throw the ball from second to first with the Yankees. Do you remember any meltdowns?

It was Steve Sax, not Chuck Knoblauch.
Steve Blass of the early 70’s Pirates was a pretty classic case of having a career meltdown. Went from a pretty good pitcher to not being able to find the plate. Out of baseball a year later.
But to compare Hill to the others? That’s a stretch…
There’s actually some evidence that hitters do better with the pitcher on-deck behind them.
Chuck Knoblauch did actually have a meltdown,Rob was accurate in that regard, Carmen. One that comes to mind is Mark Wohlers of the Braves. After the World Series he couldn’t find the plate to save his life.
Leadoff- Theriot
2nd- Johnson (earns everyday spot in cf)
3rd- D Lee
Clean up- A Ram
5th- Fukudome
6th- Derosa
7th- Soto
8th- Fontenot
9th- Pitcher
When Soriano returns, put him in the 2 hole and move Fotenot to the bench and Derosa back to 2nd. As for Pie, I would either send him to Iowa or trade him. Sorry to all you Pie lovers. He’s not doing any good sitting on the bench all week.
I don’t think Quade is really that bad. That guy the Cubs had a few years ago who kept getting people thrown out was much worse. Mistakes happen.
I am beginning to wonder if we have misread Pie. Maybe all he meant to be is a solid defensive outfielder with good speed. Sounds like a 4th outfielder who can steal bases. While that will not earn him a starting position with a team. It does make him a resource that can be leveraged. What do you think?
Yeah, as good as Pie is in the field and his speed on top of that, he is too much of a free swinger. He needs to go back to AAA and refine his swing and get back to playing consistently. That’s not going to happen with the Cubs, not with Reed Johnson playing well and producing.
Just read that Johnson will be leading off tomorrow. I’ve thought he would be the obvious choice for some time now. It’s his M.O. in the past and the man finds a way to get on base, bottom line. Can’t wait to see how it pans out. I thought it was big of Hank White to take the heat for the bunt mishap of Thursday but my finger’s pointing at Quade too!
PIE WILL ALWAYS SUCK UNTIL HE IS TRADED….THEN HE WILL IMMEDIATLEY TURN INTO LOU BROCK…
SORIANO PLAYS LF LIKE A HAPPY WAITER….
I would bring up Murton and send down either Pie or Patterson, and make the lineup Theriot, Murton, Lee, Ramirez, Fukudome, DeRosa, Soto, and Johnson.
I’m gonna have a major meltdown on Marty Brennaman
It was not Sax it was much later than that.
And I was not comparing Hill to those guys, it just reminded me of them because when he missed with the first four pitches I thought “What if he never throws a strike again?”
Cubs are 10-6, Hill picked up a win (his ERA is under 4.00), hitters provided a fun fourth inning that was enough to win the game.
Enjoy, Cubs fans!
FYI,
Looks like Murton will be back up for the time being……which I am glad to see. Hopefully he starts in LF until Soriano gets healthy again, and hopefully he hits well enough that they have a hard time sending him back down.
http://cubs.scout.com/2/747641.html
Rob, you are correct. Knoblauch couldn’t throw to 1B to save his life once he went to the Yankees. It’s why they moved him to CF.
Okay, maybe you’re thinking of Chuck, but Steve Sax suffered the same thing:
From Wikipedia:
Though never regarded as one of the top fielding second baseman in the league, Steve Sax inexplicably became incapable of making routine throws to first base in 1983, committing 30 errors that season. This is referred to in baseball terminology as “Steve Blass disease”, named after the Pirates pitcher who suffered a similar breakdown of basic mechanics. As his accuracy suffered, fans sitting behind the first base dugout began wearing batting helmets as mock protection. He apparently got over it, leading 2nd baseman in fielding percentage in 1989.
I’m a fan of Quade, and your comments are unfounded. He did make a mistake here, but I’d much prefer him over some of the other bumbling morons bouncing around the bigs. Quade hasn’t had many runners tossed out at the plate, yet I doubt you’d call him overly conservative. By and large, the Cubs DON”T miss signs, and Quade is a good addition to this team.